1621 Southridge Trail

Algonquin IL 60102

+312 617 2668

24/7 Customer Support On Line

Mon - Fri: 9:00 - 18:00

Online store always open

Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacing: Cost, Appearance, and When Each Makes Sense


cabinet refacing vs replacing

Your cabinets look tired, and the quotes you have seen range from a few thousand dollars to a number that makes you close the tab. The question under all of it is simple: are the boxes worth keeping? That is what cabinet refacing vs replacing really comes down to.

This guide compares cost, time, looks and limits, using ranges from named sources. It also shows where the sources disagree, because they do, and where the honest answer is “it depends on your boxes.”

A note on bias: a company that sells new cabinets could be tempted to push replacement. Several sources below say refacing is the better choice for sound cabinets, and I have kept that advice in.

Quick answer

Reface if your cabinet boxes are sound and you like your layout. Replace if the boxes are damaged, or you want a new layout or more storage. Sources put refacing at roughly 30 to 50 percent less than replacing custom or semi-custom cabinets, per Angi, and installation at about 3 to 5 days versus 2 to 6 weeks. The cheapest stock replacement can cost about the same as an average refacing job. Figures checked November 2026.

What each option actually changes

The cabinet refacing vs replacing choice starts with one fact: refacing keeps the cabinet boxes and changes what you see. Homes & Gardens says the box fronts are covered in new veneer or rigid thermofoil, the sides are skinned, and new door and drawer fronts and hardware go on, with new hinges if the old ones are rusty. Replacing removes the boxes and installs new ones.

Refacing Replacing
Cabinet boxes Stay; fronts and sides covered Removed and replaced
Doors and drawer fronts New New
Interior (shelves, runners) Stay as they are New
Layout Cannot change Can change
Counters and flooring Usually untouched May need work (Angi, Bob Vila)

Painting or staining is a third, cheaper option. Here is the painting route for sound cabinets if you want it.

Cost compared

In any cabinet refacing vs replacing cost comparison, costs vary a great deal by kitchen size, material and region, and the sources do not agree. Here is what each says.

Source Refacing Replacing
Angi (cost guide) $900 to $6,000 $2,000 to $30,000
Angi (reface or replace) $4,495 to $10,558 $14,608 to $41,376 (kitchen remodel)
Fixr $3,000 to $13,500, average $8,250 $4,000 to $15,000 or more
Bob Vila $4,501 to $10,546, average $7,220 Says refacing averages at least 30 to 50 percent less
Inch Calculator $1,500 to $12,500, average $7,000 Solid wood refacing about half the price of custom replacement
Kitchen Cabinet Kings (retailer) $4,000 to $9,000 for a standard kitchen $8,000 to $20,000 with a pro

The replacement column is wide because it mixes cabinet-only prices with full kitchen remodels. Check whether a quote includes countertops, flooring or plumbing before you compare.

Per linear foot, Fixr gives $100 to $450 for refacing, and HomeLight gives installed prices of $100 to $300 for stock, $200 to $650 for semi-custom and $500 to $1,200 for custom cabinets. That overlap matters, and Angi says the cheapest stock replacement costs about the same as an average refacing project.

Example (our estimate): a kitchen with 20 linear feet of cabinets would cost about $2,000 to $9,000 to reface at Fixr’s $100 to $450 per foot (20 x $100 to $450). New stock cabinets at HomeLight’s $100 to $300 per foot would be $2,000 to $6,000, and semi-custom at $200 to $650 would be $4,000 to $13,000. Counters, labor extras and removal are not included.

For full new-cabinet pricing, see the stock, RTA, semi-custom and custom prices side by side breakdown.

Watch the extras. Angi says hardware and hinges can be costly when refacing, and Home Depot says to compare the total with replacement if you need many new parts. Inch Calculator lists $300 to $500 for prep work and extra cost for reinforcing weak cabinets.

How long each takes

Refacing Replacing
Installation 3 to 5 days (Angi, Home Depot, Fixr) 2 to 4 weeks or more (Home Depot); about 6 weeks (Angi, Kitchen Cabinet Kings)
Start to finish Up to about 3 weeks including measuring and ordering (Fixr) Longer if plumbing or electrical work is involved
Kitchen use Can keep using it, per Home Depot Limited access during the project

Do not rely on the “3 to 5 days” number alone. That is installation, not the time from your first call, and your own prep and clearing add to it.

Appearance, materials and lifespan

The material you choose sets the look and the lifespan. Fixr gives these refacing materials, per linear foot.

Material Cost per linear foot (Fixr) Notes
Laminate or thermofoil $80 to $125 Can peel over time, especially with moisture
Wood veneer $100 to $250 Mid-range; cannot be refinished
Solid wood $200 to $500 Most durable and refinishable

Inch Calculator adds that veneers near a stove or moisture may have a shorter lifespan and that most contractors advise against thermofoil. Fixr puts the lifespan of refaced cabinets at 10 to 20 years or more, depending on material and workmanship.


three small cabinet door samples side by side wood veneer white thermofoil and solid wood

On looks, refacing changes the front but not the shape. You get new doors and drawer fronts, but Angi says it does not give you new boxes or change the layout. If you want an updated style, compare white and wood looks before you pick a finish, and if you want to see new styles, see new cabinet styles.

When refacing makes sense

  • Sound boxes. Angi says to reface only if your boxes are relatively new or in good condition, and Homes & Gardens says the carcass should ideally be plywood or MDF with a smooth finish.
  • A layout you like. Angi says it works if you are happy with your space and appliance locations.
  • Limited time. Home Depot says a makeover suits you if you want to avoid losing the kitchen for long.
  • A tight budget. Sources put it at roughly 30 to 50 percent below custom or semi-custom replacement.
  • Newer cabinets. Angi suggests refacing for cabinets under 20 years old.

When replacing makes sense

  • Damage. Angi lists serious damage, mold or mildew, crooked boxes and stuck drawers. Kitchen Cabinet Kings says that when boxes begin to sag or break, it is time to replace.
  • A new layout. Home Depot says refacing is not recommended if you plan to move walls, plumbing or electrical. Replacement allows a new layout, an island or more storage. For island sizes, see how to plan an island if you change the layout.
  • Storage and function. Angi says refacing cannot add pull-outs, dividers or lighting inside, and cabinets over 20 years old may only get a short-term benefit.
  • A long-term plan. If you will keep the kitchen for many years, new boxes outlast a new skin.


Photo of a base cabinet with a sagging shelf and water stained interior panel clearly damaged

If you do replace, it helps to know what is involved. See what installing new cabinets involves before you decide between DIY and a pro.

Your situation Better fit
Boxes sound, layout fine, doors dated Reface (or paint)
Boxes sagging, moldy or water-damaged Replace
Want a new layout, island or more storage Replace
Tight budget, sound boxes Reface, or paint if the doors are solid
Cabinets over 20 years old and tired Replace, per Angi

This table is my summary of the sources above, not a rule. Have the boxes looked at before you commit to either option.


Photo of a kitchen with a new open layout new base cabinets and an island

The middle path: painting or refinishing

If the doors are solid and you only want a new color, painting costs less than either route. Fixr puts refinishing at $2,000 to $4,500 for solid wood or some plywood cabinets in good structural shape, and Bob Vila puts it at $3,000 to $5,000. Painting quotes vary widely, so get local ones.

Refinishing will not fix a layout, a worn interior or a damaged box. If you want better hinges while the doors are off, check what a hinge upgrade adds before you add it to the scope.


Photo of a kitchen with freshly painted white cabinets next to the same cabinets before painting split view

Common mistakes and mental traps

  • Judging only by the doors. Look inside. Sagging shelves, swollen panels and soft spots mean refacing will not last.
  • Sunk cost. “These were expensive cabinets” is not a reason to reface damaged boxes. Past cost does not change their condition now.
  • The “while we’re at it” upgrade. Refacing turns into new counters, lighting and a new layout. If you change the layout, you are replacing.
  • Timeline optimism. The sources say 3 to 5 days for installation, but Fixr says up to about 3 weeks from first call.
  • Comparing unequal quotes. One quote may be cabinets only and another a full remodel. Ask what is included.
  • Assuming DIY saves money. Bob Vila says refacing is harder than installing cabinets and mistakes can erase savings.

Checklist

  • ☐Inspect boxes for sagging, moisture, mold and soft spots
  • ☐Decide whether the layout is staying
  • ☐Get three quotes and ask what each includes
  • ☐Price new cabinets for the same linear footage
  • ☐Compare timelines, including how long you can go without the kitchen
  • ☐Check the installer’s warranty
  • ☐Choose the material for your moisture and heat conditions

Frequently asked questions

Is cabinet refacing cheaper than replacing?

Usually. Angi says it is roughly 30 to 50 percent cheaper than custom or semi-custom replacement, though the cheapest stock replacement can cost about the same as an average refacing job.

How long does cabinet refacing take?

About 3 to 5 days for installation, per Fixr, Angi and Home Depot. Fixr says up to about 3 weeks from the first contractor call.

Can refacing change my kitchen layout?

No. Angi says refacing cannot change the layout, and the interior of the boxes stays the same. Replacement can. ask for help comparing your two options if you are unsure.

How long do refaced cabinets last?

Fixr says 10 to 20 years or more, depending on material and workmanship. The boxes themselves are only as old as they were, so a short life remains for old cabinets.

Should I do refacing myself?

Bob Vila and Kitchen Cabinet Kings both say refacing is hard to DIY and recommend a pro. For ordering questions, see answers before you order.

Final thoughts

The cabinet refacing vs replacing decision is easier than it looks. Refacing is a good choice when the boxes are solid and the layout works. Replacing is the right choice when the boxes are failing or the kitchen has to work differently. The money you save by refacing only pays off if the cabinets last long enough to justify it.

Before you decide, open every cabinet and look. The boxes will tell you most of what you need to know.

Leaning toward new cabinets?

See available styles, then ask for help comparing a replacement with what you have.

Browse cabinet collections
Get design or quote help

Scroll to Top